It must have an independent entity at the end of all the objects. The universe cannot exist in any other fashion. There must be a superior at the end of the chain that grants the request. If this chain of seeking permission never ends, and there is no one who requires no further permission in the chain, will Dave ever get to paint his office walls blue? Of course not. This boss must ask his superior for permission, and that superior his own superior. One must eventually stop lining dominoes at some point, in order to set them in motion.ĭave wants to paint his office walls blue, but, in order to do so must ask permission from his boss. Will one ever get to flick and set the dominoes in motion? Of course not. If one is setting dominos in a line, and for each domino that is standing, must set another domino behind it in the line, lining up dominoes without end. Two concrete examples to illustrate this, first example: There needs to be an independent entity in the series, that requires nothing else, to end the chain of dependency. If every object in a series requires another object in order to exist, the dependencies can never be fulfilled. If object A requires > B requires > C requires > D requires > E. The problem with a never-ending chain of dependencies. (Naturally, this is a simplified chain of dependencies, as an object is typically dependent on numerous other objects, which in turn are dependent on many other objects.) (Each item in this series is dependent on the next item to maintain its existence) Substantial top-level comments | Reported as: Substantial top-level comments | Responses to posts should engage substantially with the content of the post, either by refutation or else expounding upon a position within the argument.Įverything in this universe is dependent upon something else (in order to maintain its conditions of existence).įlower > Nutrient-dense soil > Intact atmosphere > Specific distance of orbit around sun > Sun interacting with forces from other stars in the galaxy > larger interactions of forces between galaxies. Some other subreddits that may be more appropriate for your post are r/DebateEvolution, r/DebateReligion, and r/DebateAChristian. To ask a general question, do so in our pinned, bi-weekly threads or visit r/AskAnAtheist. Present an argument or discussion topic | Reported as: Off-topic post | Posts should be related to atheism and have a topic to debate. Write substantial comments that address other users’ points. No Low Effort | Reported as: Low effort | Do not create low effort posts or comments. If things become heated, use the report function or walk away. All comments containing any amount of incivility will be removed, and repeat offenses will receive a swift ban. You may attack ideas or even public figures so long as you do so civilly, but not users of the sub. Comments and posts may not insult, demean, personally attack, or intentionally provoke any user. Rules:īe Respectful | Reported as: Be respectful | Be respectful of other users on the subreddit.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |